In a small town in the middle of the Gila Wilderness, a class of rambunctious 4- and 5-year-old pre-K students released 32 healthy butterflies just before the end of the school year. It was the culmination of several weeks of observation and learning about the butterfly life cycle. It was also a lesson in patience, breathtaking growth, and transformation — fitting both for the year we had and for the transition to kindergarten the little ones were experiencing.

This experience was possible — perhaps surprisingly, given how often such an occurrence is not the case — not out of my own pocket but with the support of administration and out of our school’s operational budget. A budget that largely depends on oil and gas. A budget that is at risk as oil and gas production is limited in New Mexico.

In 2020, the state’s oil and gas industry contributed $1.4 billion to New Mexico Education. Schools in Catron County, though on the opposite side of the state from “oil country,” are dependent on the revenue generated from the oil and gas industry as well. In fact, our county alone received $1.241 million in education funding from oil and gas in 2020, and those dollars made everything from entire positions to interactive learning projects — like our butterfly release — possible. The funds also proved invaluable in a year where additional technology, custodial hours and multiplied resources were necessary. To imagine what challenges not having those funds this year would have presented is daunting. Further, to imagine the impacts of not having immersive and cross-content learning experiences due to an unnecessary budget depletion is devastating.

The National Assessment of Education Progress, or “The Nation’s Report Card,” as it is more commonly known, is an assessment that provides comparative data for schools across the nation, and results reported in 2019 show that New Mexico only outperformed Alabama and Puerto Rico in math and literacy student achievement. Our students and families deserve better. Teachers require more resources — we know this, and yet we still rank only 42nd in per-pupil spending.

Frankly, to limit the revenue of oil and gas would be a monumental loss in a system that already is not providing what our students and families need in order to be competitive in a modern economy. Education and economy exist in a cycle where each supports the other. In New Mexico, this is a cycle that both educationally and economically cannot survive the limitation of such a vital industry.

New Mexico can and absolutely should support economic growth and diversity, but this does not have to be done at the cost of limiting our state’s most successful private industry, one that makes so much possible for New Mexicans. As the demand for energy grows, there is no better place for that energy to be produced than here, in our own state, where environmental protections are some of the strongest in the world and where we can continue to benefit from the essential revenue it creates. Rather than limiting opportunity, this teacher hopes for an abundance, not only so I can continue to provide rich learning experiences, but also for the children in my classroom, so that they feel they can stay in New Mexico, that they have the chance to thrive as adults in the state they call home.

There is plenty of room for oil and gas to continue to provide jobs and revenue while new and diversified economic opportunity is explored and expanded. These ideas are not mutually exclusive, but rather, by the educational and economic cycle, dependent upon each other.

Kayli Ortiz is prekindergarten teacher at Reserve Elementary in Reserve.

(4) comments

Mike Johnson

Well said Ms. Ortiz, and those of us who recognize the important and irreplaceable contributions of the petroleum industry to NM's economy and educational systems totally agree. But, the left wing eco-socialist forces, who believe capitalism (especially the petroleum industry) and the environment are not mutually compatible will continue to try and remove the industry ASAP, and of course there is nothing to take its place except poverty and economic decline in this state.

Jim Klukkert

G'afternoon Mike. As one friend to another, with the mutual respect that allows each of us to disagree with the other:

Nothing is more characteristic of an aridified and desiccated desert suffering the long term effects of fossil fuel driven extreme drought, than "poverty and economic decline."

I agree we are headed to that result, but I would say it is the result of socially irresponsible practices by the largely unregulated fossil fuel industry. [Did I hear you wince when you read "largely unregulated?" ;~}]

You have another take, I am sure.

Just as I am sure there is at least a measure of truth in your take, I am comfortable with my analysis.

Some speculate that those effects drove the fracturing of the Syrian state, when rural farmer folks flooded urban areas looking for refuge from the drought stricken agricultural areas. But I suppose, that story will wait for another day.

Most sincerely, have a good day Mike. The fact that we can reasonably disagree, is a comfort to me in these challenging times.

Mike Johnson

Thank you Jim, yes we do disagree on the details here, as a paleoclimatologist (yes with many years in the petroleum industry too), my educational background and understanding of the earth's climate systems and history gives me pause to blame forces that may have political attributes and motives when causation is attributed to what have always been natural phenomena throughout earth's history. I feel the science is not settled in causation, though I would not dispute man is altering climate to a degree, and I also know single factor correlation in a complex physiological-chemical system like climate is questionable for long term projections of transient phenomena. I hope you have a good day and enjoy the nice humid and rainy weather we are having lately.

Jim Klukkert

What a marvelous image, "a class of rambunctious 4- and 5-year-old pre-K students released 32 healthy butterflies," and how in tune with the beauty of our natural environment.

And how devious and manipulative, to set the tone for an article encouraging the further catastrophic destruction of that same environment, as well as the catastrophic destruction of any future for those children, by the continued use of fossil fuels.

Keep it in the ground already. The archaic, destructive practices of the extraction industries must stop. FULL STOP.

How sad that teachers like Kayli Ortiz are so poorly informed on the world’s existential crisis, or so bankrupt that they would advocate for such a destructive course.

Welcome to the discussion.

Thank you for joining the conversation on Please familiarize yourself with the community guidelines. Avoid personal attacks: Lively, vigorous conversation is welcomed and encouraged, insults, name-calling and other personal attacks are not. No commercial peddling: Promotions of commercial goods and services are inappropriate to the purposes of this forum and can be removed. Respect copyrights: Post citations to sources appropriate to support your arguments, but refrain from posting entire copyrighted pieces. Be yourself: Accounts suspected of using fake identities can be removed from the forum.