Gerald Peters is the crab in our Santa Fe bucket we love to pull down.

It’s almost too easy. Reclusive and private, he owns a bank, an art gallery and a lot of commercial property. And now beautiful acreage on Upper Cow Creek, where he plans to develop luxury home sites. That’s a lot of targets on someone’s back.

I’ve been in Santa Fe’s building and development game for 36 years and never met him. But we apparently share a love for Cow Creek. He’s at his end; we’re at ours, far downstream.

Cow Creek is an interesting 30-mile stretch of Pecos River watershed. It’s shown on the earliest crude maps of the region but didn’t see Spanish homesteading until Pecos Pueblo people walked to Jemez Pueblo and the Comanche and Apache were eradicated or transplanted.

Diverging from the Pecos River but still close to the Santa Fe Trail and railroad, it sprung three villages along its reaches. Upper Colonias, just downstream for Peters’ place, then Lower Colonias, then North San Ysidro. It connects to the Pecos River just north of San Jose near Interstate 25.

The spring-fed creek, with minor tributaries along its twisty course, is a significant contributor to the flow of the Pecos River, upon which so many are dependent, all the way to Del Rio, Texas.

Families settling the area were hardy. Roybal, Gonzalez, Valencia, Padilla, Ruiz, Aragon are family names I know; undoubtedly there are more. It was subsistence living, with small, flat food-growing flood plains strung together like linked sausages switching from side to side along the canyon floor.



Red willows and box elder maple got dug up and cleared. Acequias were ditched along upper edges and held tight by fruit tree roots. It was all one could want, if the hail and the frost and the floods and the dry spells were gentle and kind.

Over the years, young families moved out of the land grant villages and homesteaded other stretches of the creek. Our 400 yards of creek frontage, between Lower Colonias and North San Ysidro, and two villages and 20 miles from Peters, sits between lands belonging at one time to Roybals to the north and Gonzaleses to the south.

Families then prayed to be big so many hands could help feed many mouths. The rugged, steep hills are dotted with 100-year-old ax-cut stumps of slow-rotting, hot-burning juniper — perfect for the horno. When the Depression and Dust Bowl swept across America in the 1930s, life got harder, but it was always hard.

Great changes came with World War II. It nearly emptied the villages. Boys went off to fight, and other boys and girls went to war jobs in Colorado and California. They seldom came back. Acequias filled in. Cows, sheep and goats ceased trampling creek banks. Willows and box elder maple came back for the beavers. Fields grew over. The remnants of hand-built homes of rock, logs and mud still crumble.

All the villages are still somewhat populated, and big school buses from Pecos still pick up a kid or two, but all save retirees drive somewhere every day for work. Nobody lives exclusively off the land anymore. Which is to say the health of the creek has benefitted tremendously from being fallow for decades and with a fraction of its peak population.

As long as Peters’ plan is luxury ranchettes for part-time ricos, and there are strong covenants for on-site septic treatment and minimal water use, I’m not too worried about effects on our pristine stretch of light-footprint stewardship.

Kim Shanahan has been a Santa Fe green builder since 1986 and a sustainability consultant since 2019. Contact him at shanafe@aol.com.

(8) comments

Grace Trujillo

It's the local people's fault for letting all these rich people come in and purchase everything. Now Gerald wants to create a development in the mountains.

YEAH, mess up the one peaceful place that we can go on vacation (because that's the closest place) and relax and enjoy the forests. Mr. Peters, have some compassion for the people here in Pecos and Santa Fe that can not afford a proper vacation to anywhere in the world that you can. I vacation spot will be destroyed. Please don't do it!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Emily Hartigan

So the author is already privileged enough to book-end Peters in this location?

Lupe Molina

I don't know Peters either but I do know from loving here that employees at his businesses are treated poorly and he may have made his first chuck of money in Santa Fe selling drugs. Rumor? Perhaps. But it's pretty unusual to hear only bad things about someone very few have ever met. Block the development. He's a bad dude who doesn't need the money.

Lisa Bronowicz

Gerald Peters has been an easy target because he's long been a person that others love to hate. There's always been an element of jealousy involved in their emotions too. But you are correct in that strict covenants will prevent horrible damage. Look at the size of the tract and how much of it (not that much) he wants to develop. Another developer might not be so considerate of the people who live there and of the environment. I worked for Mr. Peters once, and I would say that his development will be done very well and beautifully.

Elizabeth Denham

Oh terrific! Let’s continue to give away ancestral land to wealthy people and force the people who lived there for generations to work at Walmart.Good job, Gerald Peters!

Jeff Varela

And...you sir are part of the problem

Andrew Lucero

[thumbup][thumbup][thumbup][thumbup][thumbup]

Richard Reinders

Who’s land did you take.

Welcome to the discussion.

Thank you for joining the conversation on Santafenewmexican.com. Please familiarize yourself with the community guidelines. Avoid personal attacks: Lively, vigorous conversation is welcomed and encouraged, insults, name-calling and other personal attacks are not. No commercial peddling: Promotions of commercial goods and services are inappropriate to the purposes of this forum and can be removed. Respect copyrights: Post citations to sources appropriate to support your arguments, but refrain from posting entire copyrighted pieces. Be yourself: Accounts suspected of using fake identities can be removed from the forum.