The Spanish fraternal organization Union Protectíva de Santa Fé is asking the city's Ethics and Campaign Review Board to dismiss a complaint claiming the organization engaged in illicit political activity to try to unseat Mayor Alan Webber in this fall's election.

The complaint, filed last month by Webber's campaign, alleges Union Protectíva violated city code and state law by failing to register as a political committee. The ethics board is expected to discuss the complaint Thursday.

Union Protectíva has been vocal in its opposition to Webber and his decision to remove a statue of conquistador Don Diego de Vargas from a downtown park last year. It also has been critical of the city's Culture, History, Art, Reconciliation and Truth process in newspaper advertisements and social media posts.

In a response filed Thursday with the ethics board, Union Protectíva argued it is not a political committee, saying its "principal purpose" is to preserve Santa Fe's Hispanic heritage.

The group also said its views were protected under the First Amendment.

Its ad about the CHART process "identifies Mayor Webber but does not even faintly suggest that anyone should vote for or against him," the group said in its response to the complaint. "Indeed, it does not even mention the upcoming municipal election. In short, the most reasonable interpretation of the advertisement is that the speaker is unhappy with Mayor Webber. The First Amendment robustly protects that speech."

In an interview, James Hallinan, the organization's spokesman, said: "Just because Union Protectíva is calling out the mayor for his irresponsible, and what we believe to be illegal, behavior with our monuments does not mean he can abuse the system and file a frivolous, knowingly frivolous, complaint just to retaliate."

In an email, Sascha Guinn Anderson, Webber's campaign spokeswoman, said: "Union Protectiva clearly engaged in electioneering and voters deserve to know how attack ads are being funded. Transparency and disclosure are basic tenets of Santa Fe's election code and no one should be above the law."

(7) comments

paul pacheco

La Union Protectiva is an organization dedicated to preserving and enhancing the Spanish culture of La Villa Real de la Santa Fe de San Francisco de Assis. The organizations’ role is to intercede for its people when politics and politicians such as Webber infringe and try to crush the culture in any way, shape, or form. Long live the Spanish settlers of Santa Fe y Que Viva Santa Fe’. With a politically created commission in place, I see a lawsuit coming down the pipe!

Lupe Molina

That's all well and good Paul. But if they are also going to advocate for the Mayor's ouster, they need to be registered as a political committee.

Richard Reinders


Stefanie Beninato

Thanks, Lupe. I was going to bring up the same thing. La Union Protectiva's main mission is to help bury the dead. Did the members jump at the chance to help rebury the remains found in the PERA parking lot? I did not hear anything about its efforts in that case. Am I surprised? No? They are part of Vigil-Coppler's attack dogs.

Richard Reinders

Stefanie, it is not La Union Protectiva's only mission.

LeRoy Sanchez

So true.

Lupe Molina

One reaps what they sow. Attack ads are political speech and there's a lot of legal precedent for it. Also, that is not the stated mission of the organization which is described on their own website as "Our group’s first mission and continues to this day, is to aid both monetarily and spiritually in proper Christian burials for our members and aid their families in their time of need." Sorry, dudes. Don't think you're getting out of this one.

Welcome to the discussion.

Thank you for joining the conversation on Please familiarize yourself with the community guidelines. Avoid personal attacks: Lively, vigorous conversation is welcomed and encouraged, insults, name-calling and other personal attacks are not. No commercial peddling: Promotions of commercial goods and services are inappropriate to the purposes of this forum and can be removed. Respect copyrights: Post citations to sources appropriate to support your arguments, but refrain from posting entire copyrighted pieces. Be yourself: Accounts suspected of using fake identities can be removed from the forum.