Court files: New Mexico man shot infant, sought to kill mom

Shayanne Nelson and Tyrell Bitsilly

GALLUP — A man has admitted he was the one who accidentally shot an infant girl, not her 3-year-old brother, and then tried to arrange the killing of the baby’s mother and a key witness, new court documents allege.

Tyrell Bitsilly told authorities he fired the weapon that left the baby partially blind and deaf, according to court documents released last week, the Gallup Independent reported.

Bitsilly, 21, and the baby’s mother, Shayanne Nelson, had told police the girl’s 3-year-old brother found a gun left in a Gallup motel room and accidentally fired it.

The child abuse case took an unexpected turn last week when Gallup police served Bitsilly a warrant on suspicion he was seeking to arrange the killing of Nelson and a retired military medic who helped save the infant girl’s life.

“Tyrell Bitsilly believed that Shayanne Nelson was going to testify against him because she knew what really happened that night,” Gallup Detective Chavo Chischilly wrote in the arrest warrant. “Tyrell Bitsilly also knew that he would end up in prison for 18 years or more.”

In June, Nelson, now 19, pleaded guilty to child abuse and agreed to testify against Bitsilly, her boyfriend, as part of her plea agreement.

Chischilly wrote Bitsilly also wanted the paramedic, Casey Franchot, killed because Franchot witnessed him wiping off fingerprints from the gun with a rag. Bitsilly is now charged with criminal solicitation to commit first-degree murder and bribery of a witness.

Chischilly reported that FBI Agent Ken Fetcher contacted him Aug. 27 because he received information that Bitsilly wanted to find someone to kill Nelson and Franchot.

Public defender Alec Orenstein said he needed more time to talk to Bitsilly about the new allegations.

“It’s complicated enough that we need to get this case assigned to someone to take care of all these matters before making a recommendation,” Orenstein said. “We’re severely short-staffed and don’t have the resources to handle this case right now.”

Bitsilly remains in custody. A jury trial in the child abuse case is scheduled for Dec. 10.

(1) comment

Michael Grimler

I'm just SHOCKED that the original story they told police was a lie.

Shocked, I tell you!


Welcome to the discussion.

Thank you for joining the conversation on Please familiarize yourself with the community guidelines. Avoid personal attacks: Lively, vigorous conversation is welcomed and encouraged, insults, name-calling and other personal attacks are not. No commercial peddling: Promotions of commercial goods and services are inappropriate to the purposes of this forum and can be removed. Respect copyrights: Post citations to sources appropriate to support your arguments, but refrain from posting entire copyrighted pieces. Be yourself: Accounts suspected of using fake identities can be removed from the forum.