House committee advances measure to remove mountain lion protections

Brandon Griffith of the New Mexico Department of Game and Fish prepares to transport a cougar for release into the wild in 2010. Clyde Mueller/The New Mexican

Cougars would become an unprotected species in New Mexico under a bill that advanced Friday in the Legislature.

The House Agriculture, Water and Wildlife Committee sent the measure forward without recommendation on an 8-2 vote.

The bill would overturn the law that requires a license to hunt cougars. Instead, the mountain cats could be shot or trapped at any time and in any number, putting them in the same league as skunks and coyotes.

Animals are the focus of a number of high-profile bills. Last week, the House wildlife committee killed a bill to outlaw coyote-killing contests. But the full House of Representatives has approved a bill to better protect animals in zoos by adding a criminal penalty.

Rep. Zach Cook, R-Ruidoso, is sponsoring the measure to eliminate protection of cougars, which he called “a cleanup bill,” not one of significant change. Former state game and fish director Jim Lane, serving as Cook’s expert, did most of the talking. He presented the bill as “a common-sense” means of better controlling cougar populations.

Lane said cougars inhabit parts of the state that hunters never reach, so the bill would not threaten to make them extinct. He said 2,000 to 2,500 hunting licenses for cougars are sold in New Mexico each year, but kills number only about 200.

Former state senator Tim Jennings, a Democrat from Roswell, held a stuffed lamb as he testified for the bill. He said the sheep industry once flourished in New Mexico, and predators are one of the main reasons for its steep decline.

Ranchers testified that they have been plagued by drought and cannot afford the losses of livestock caused by cougars. And Republican Rep. Andy Nuñez, a committee member from Hatch who voted for the bill, said he saw an enormous cougar prowling a golf course in Las Cruces. Nuñez said mountains cats are encroaching on cities.

Opponents of the bill far outnumbered those who supported it.

They said Cook’s bill was devoid of any science and called it “a knee-jerk reaction” to anecdotal reports of runaway cougar populations killing pets and livestock.

John Crenshaw of the New Mexico Wildlife Federation testified against the bill, saying it was flawed because it removes protection for females and even cubs.

Other critics of the bill said it is illogical, taking away the legal authority of professionals in the state Department of Game and Fish to manage cougar populations.

William Wiley, of the state chapter of Republicans for Environmental Protection, condemned the proposal. “I am full of fury, and I am full of disgust for this bill,” he said.

A woman from Albuquerque had a similar assessment: “The only killing that should be done today is to kill this bill,” she said.

The Department of Game and Fish “conservatively estimated” that 3,000 to 4,500 cougars inhabit New Mexico.

Alexandra Sandoval, director of the department, said her agency would have no legal authority to respond to complaints about cougars if the bill were approved and signed into law by the governor. She said the department estimates that 700 kills of cougars annually would be the right management number, but it is proceeding with tracking some lions with GPS collars in hopes of getting a better understanding of the population.

Democratic Reps. Bill McCamley of Mesilla Park and Bobby Gonzales of Taos voted against the bill. A mix of Democrats and Republicans supported it.

The bill has two more committee assignments in the House of Representatives. If it clears both, it would reach the full 70-member House for a floor vote.

Contact Milan Simonich at 986-3080 or Follow his Ringside Seat column and blog at

Show what you're thinking about this story

You must be logged in to react.
Click any reaction to login.

(12) comments

Claudia Wolfe

Kill the bill not the cougars!!!! "common sense" bill not based on facts but antidotes - this is a HORRIBLE and despicable bill of murder on a species that does not deserve cold and callus consideration. We have been responsible for endangering so many species - must we continue this behavior. Shame on our legislators

Claudia Wolfe

John Wilson

I wish I could require all of those who voted for this travesty of a bill to read one of the great New Mexican authors, Aldo Leopold. (Wisconsin also claims him but they are just latecomers).

The concept of science-based game management was the subject of 'Game Management' Leopold wrote in 1933 would be useful as a base of information. If they were to read 'Sand County Almanac', the concept of environmental ethics might soak in.

Legislation like this makes us look like ignorant yahoos.

Khal Spencer

"...Legislation like this makes us look like ignorant yahoos."

You are being nice..

Janet Eduardo

Is there ANYTHING aimed at ruining the state that the republican run house WON'T vote for?


This is a good bill, because we need to make life easier for lazy ranchers who can't be bothered to take relatively easy measures to protect their herds/flocks while they exploit our public lands for their private profit.

Khal Spencer

I suppose the next travesty will be organized "kill as many as you can" cat hunts. As long as people like Jim Lane are heading up fish and game agencies, we can continue to expect unscientific, early twentieth century solutions like "kill the varmints" rather than scientific wildlife management.

Maybe this will find a quick death in one of the other committees.

Alasdair Lindsay

Wow, I can finally start to feel safe now that the go ahead to kill wild animals is moving ahead in the legislature. These wild animals help control a balance in the ecosystem and are struggling in our changing climate. Farmers and ranchers along with the legislature want to sterilize our environment. Mr. Nunez will soon be able to bring a rifle along in his golf bag to ensure his safety on the golf course. I am so glad we have such an informed legislature to protect us from all of these obscure threats!

Ranch Girl

This is sickening.

Khal Spencer

Dumb, dumb, dumb idea.

karl hardy

Nuñez said mountains cats are encroaching on cities..........WRONG... THE CITIES HAVE ENCROACHED ON THE MOUNTAIN CATS HABITAT..........

Ginny Vigil


Khal Spencer


Welcome to the discussion.

Thank you for joining the conversation on Please familiarize yourself with the community guidelines. Avoid personal attacks: Lively, vigorous conversation is welcomed and encouraged, insults, name-calling and other personal attacks are not. No commercial peddling: Promotions of commercial goods and services are inappropriate to the purposes of this forum and can be removed. Respect copyrights: Post citations to sources appropriate to support your arguments, but refrain from posting entire copyrighted pieces. Be yourself: Accounts suspected of using fake identities can be removed from the forum.