A high-ranking legislative staffer who made disparaging remarks about Native Americans has sent a letter of apology to New Mexico pueblos and tribes.

In a letter sent Wednesday to the Navajo Nation and the All Pueblo Council of Governors, among others, Rachel Gudgel, head of the Legislative Education Study Committee, wrote, “As has been been heavily reported, I made some isolated, insensitive comments about Native Americans and Native American education in 2019 that were insulting and harmful.”

She added she regretted her “ignorant choice of words and cavalier attitude and apologize to New Mexico tribal leadership and their communities, families and children.”

Gudgel, who became director of the committee in 2016, came under scrutiny earlier this year when it was reported five workers put together a three-page list of grievances about her — including charges she disparaged Native Americans — in 2020.

Those workers also criticized her management style.

Lawmakers on the Legislative Education Study Committee recently deadlocked over the issue of whether to fire Gudgel. The 5-5 vote means she gets to keep her job.

Some of those lawmakers were criticized for not being more open about the process, which, some of them said, should remain confidential because it is a personnel matter.

Gudgel alluded to this in her letter, noting her decision to “remain quiet until now was based on the fact that this is and was a part of a confidential personnel matter reviewed by my employer and the process and knowledge that my employer’s reprimand and corrective action addressed this sad and unfortunate chapter in my government career.”

In the letter, Gudgel wrote she had spoken with Navajo Nation officials.

“These conversations have been very humbling for me and provide a needed understanding to be more culturally sensitive and effective on behalf of all New Mexicans, particularly our Pueblos, Tribes and Nations,” she wrote.

Speaking by phone Wednesday night, Gudgel said she sent the letter because, “This is taking away from the job that we all have, which is focusing on the kids. My greatest hope is that we can get back to doing that in a meaningful, collaborative way.”

She said she was not pressured to write or send the letter by any lawmaker. She said she couldn’t comment further about the personnel issue.

She said she planned to send the letter to the individual leaders of the state’s pueblos Thursday morning.

Reached by phone Wednesday night, Rep. Derrick Lente, D-Sandia Pueblo, who publicly called for Gudgel’s removal last week, said that while he had not seen the letter, the apology “is appreciated.”

Still, he said many Native Americans “may still very much be offended by the whole situation.”

He said he would still like to see some “sort of action related to the individual [Gudgel].”

Efforts to reach Sen. Bill Soules, chairman of the study committee, were unsuccessful Wednesday night.

In her letter, Gudgel said she looked forward to “put these events behind me” in hopes of working with “the Tribes, Nations and Pueblos of New Mexico to focus on the great challenges Native students face.”

She ended her letter by writing, “I again sincerely and humbly ask for your forgiveness. I was wrong and am deeply sorry.”

General Assignment Reporter

Robert Nott has covered education and youth issues for the Santa Fe New Mexican. He is assigned to The New Mexican's city desk where he covers a general assignment beat.

(18) comments

Khal Spencer

"I wish to apologize but its tough to sign the apology letter while my arm is being twisted"

Judy Montoya

Too little too late. It makes me think of something my husband once said (he is native american) the great spirit gave us two eyes, two ears, and ONE mouth.

Listen twice as much, see twice as much, and talk half as much!

Emily Hartigan

She can't comment on personnel issues?

Excuse me, but you are the person in personnel. You can comment.

Jerry Appel

This is a first step. Making sure Gudgel goes away for a months-long sensitivity training would also be quite useful. A pay cut would also be useful to let her know she really screwed up, say 50 percent.

Mike Johnson

I'm sorry, any white male conservative who did this would have been fired. She should be treated equally.

Mark Ortiz

LMAO, The old white males are under assault argument. Well, maybe soon people of color will take it easy on you someday soon because Lord knows ya'll have struggled immensely in this country even before it was a country. #FreeWhiteMalesNow!!!

rodney carswell

He's clueless

Khal Spencer

If I recall correctly, Mark Moores got raked over the coals by the Left for putting his foot in his mouth. If that is the standard, it should be for everybody.

Mike Johnson


Mike Johnson

Oh, OK, all solved, nothing going on here, move along......

Peter Romero

I feel that same way about being called "lizard people". oversensitivity is rampant, The media plays us with this tabloid reporting. please just respect each other like humans.

Prince Michael Jauregui

Mr. Romero, you make some valid points. Still, public officials at all levels must be held accountable.

Perhaps, if Gudgel's apology is truly sincere, she can pledge to partnership with Native communities and create awareness.

Peter Romero

I agree, how do we as a society determine if it was "Truly Sincere" ?

I never really care for apologies after the fact in most situations.

Mark Ortiz

"In the letter, Gudgel wrote she had spoken with Navajo Nation officials.

“These conversations have been very humbling for me and provide a needed understanding to be more culturally sensitive and effective on behalf of all New Mexicans, particularly our Pueblos, Tribes and Nations,” she wrote."

To reporter Robert Nott, I highly suggest you find out if these conversations happened, with who, and if they will share what was said, and how they feel now. I'm going to bet it was a handful at best. Also, what about the abuse in here office, her subordinates. I can guarantee she is not going to change her managerial "style."

Sadly the Governor has stayed silent on this. Gudgel really needs to go and not be hired in NM State government in any capacity.

Vince Czarnowski

It's absolutely disgusting that she is able to get away with this.

Al Chavez

The correct response, "I'm very, very sorry for making prejudicial statements. I hereby resign."

Prince Michael Jauregui

Suddenly, she's "sorry"?

Vaya con queso.

Andrew Lucero

Just issuing an apology now? Gee, I bet it was soooooooo sincere and heartfelt that even Bill Clinton could feel her pain.

Welcome to the discussion.

Thank you for joining the conversation on Santafenewmexican.com. Please familiarize yourself with the community guidelines. Avoid personal attacks: Lively, vigorous conversation is welcomed and encouraged, insults, name-calling and other personal attacks are not. No commercial peddling: Promotions of commercial goods and services are inappropriate to the purposes of this forum and can be removed. Respect copyrights: Post citations to sources appropriate to support your arguments, but refrain from posting entire copyrighted pieces. Be yourself: Accounts suspected of using fake identities can be removed from the forum.