A recent commentary by Andres Oppenheimer entitled, "Angry migrant underclass could possibly erupt" and published in this newspaper, struck a sensitive nerve — mostly because I've for years supported a humane immigration bill that allows immigrants to work here legally and, depending on their behavior and other factors, permit the granting
of citizenship. By immigrants I mean people from other countries, not just Mexicans.
The other reason the piece struck a chord is the fact that I've
been in the countries that Oppenheimer mentions when the boiling
resentments of immigrants has turned into rioting and demonstrations.
Less than a week ago, my wife and I were in Rome when a huge
government motorcade interrupted traffic in the city. When we inquired
what the occasion was, we were informed that the Romanian president was
meeting with Italy's prime minister. The reason for the meeting was the
growing tensions and racism against Romanians after a Romanian
immigrant had killed the wife of a naval officer.
Just days ago neo-Nazi groups and ultra right-wing fanatics were
planning demonstrations in Madrid. The debate there is whether the
government should step in and ban the demonstrations, especially in
light of the fact that these groups are targeting immigrants. These
same groups issued a manifesto against any immigrant who was not
"Spanish" born.
Thousands of "illegal" Africans land on Spain's Canary Islands,
many dying on the sea trying to get into mainland Spain and the rest of
Europe. Most, with the help of the European Union, are intercepted,
cared for and sent back to their country of origin.
The issue of "illegal" immigration is a worldwide phenomenon, and
reactions are international although we believe, in our isolation, that
we are the only country that has these issues. As long as Western
populations, including the U.S., need workers either because of zero
population growth or the fact that many Americans don't want to pick
the oranges, lettuce, apples, etc. or work in meat-packing plants, we
will need immigrants.
The difference between the U.S. and the EU is that the EU leaders
have held summits, proposed ideas, and implemented plants to deal, in a
humane way, with the myriad issues that accompany both legal and
"illegal" immigration.
In this country, as Oppenheimer states, "We are creating an
underclass of people who won't leave the country and, realistically,
can't be deported. They and their children are living with no prospect
of earning a legal status, no matter how hard they work for it. Many of
them will become increasingly frustrated, angry, and some of them
eventually could turn violent."
One prays that this does not happen as it has occurred in Western
Europe. However, if the racist, xenophobic hysteria does not subside in
Congress and meaningful and humane legislation does not result, we may
indeed have the same problems.
And recently returning from Europe where the dollar is worth only
50 Europoean cents and many workers working for U.S. companies are
asking to be paid in euros rather than in dollars, I contemplate the
fall of our economy and a worthless dollar. We have to place ourselves
in the shoes of the immigrant. If the dollar continues to sink, our
trade partners lose faith in our economy, and the war continues to
drive us into poverty, we too could become emigrants. We as Americans
have arrogantly believed that we will forever be immune to an economic
crises.
We'd better wake up soon, for the immigrants' problem could soon
be our very own. We, in our arrogance, balk and believe this will never
happen to us. One thing that will happen is that the immigrant is not
going to go away and issues of whether drivers licenses should be
issued to immigrants, whether rentals should be denied to them, make
matters only worse. The country must come up with a comprehensive plan
that deals with all these issues humanely and not just for the
immigrants' sake but for the sake of our own conscience and soul to do
what is right.
Writer/historian Orlando Romero can be reached at nambe1@aol.com.
You must register with a valid email address and use your real name to comment on this forum. Previous usernames are no longer valid as of Feb. 5. Once you've logged into the system, you'll be able to contribute comments. If you need help logging in or establishing your new user name and password, please visit this tutorial.
All users are expected to abide by the forum rules and and be courteous to other users. Comments can be accepted up to eight days following publication. After that, comments can be read but no new submissions made. Send questions to webeditor@sfnewmexican.com
IMPORTANT: Comments must be posted under your own full, real name. Anonymous comments and those posted under a pseudonym can be removed. Please consult the forum rules. If you have questions, e-mail webeditor@sfnewmexican.com.