It appears that for a second year, Hanna Skandera won't win confirmation as the state's Public Education Department secretary.
There is no law prohibiting the former Florida deputy commissioner
of education from continuing to serve as Gov. Susana Martinez's choice
to oversee New Mexico school systems.
However, it's unlikely that the Senate Rules Committee will schedule
a confirmation hearing for Skandera before midday Thursday, when time
runs out on the 2012 legislative session.
The "why" of it all is being left somewhat vague by those in control
of the confirmation process, but they express concerns with how
Skandera has meshed with various segments of the state's educational
community as she tries to steer the new Republican administration's
reform efforts.
"I do agree we need to have a thorough hearing on Ms. Skandera, but
it's just a matter of balancing our remaining time," said Sen. Linda
Lopez, D-Albuquerque, who chairs the committee and schedules hearings.
"There are so many questions and concerns about what has happened
here in the time that she has been in office. ... If we need to have a
hearing, we would need to engage communities from across the state."
Though she did not offer specifics, Lopez indicated that Skandera
has not been effective in reaching out to educational leaders in the
state.
José Armas of the Latino/Hispano Education Improvement Task Force, in an opinion piece published last week in
The New Mexican,
called Skandera "a non-educator and outsider" who "came armed, not with
education skills, but with an ideological agenda. From the start, it
was Skandera's agenda vs. 70 percent of New Mexico's multicultural
populations."
Skandera is the only one of the governor's appointees not to receive a confirmation hearing this session.
Asked Tuesday morning whether she had heard anything regarding a
possible confirmation hearing, Skandera said simply, "I'm focusing on
the [education] bills." She said she plans to remain in her position: "I
came to New Mexico to do a job, and I plan to do that job."
Since joining Martinez's administration in January 2011, Skandera --
who served under Florida's Republican Gov. Jeb Bush from 2005 to 2007
-- has successfully lobbied for an A-to-F school grading system, which
will officially become law in August. In January, the Public Education
Department released preliminary baseline grades for the state's 830
schools, giving New Mexico an overall grade of C.
About 125 of those schools, including two Santa Fe-based charter
schools, have appealed their grades, which were determined via a number
of complex factors that haven't yet been entirely explained to school
districts.
Last week, the U.S. Department of Education announced that New
Mexico is the only one of 11 states that applied for waivers from the
federally mandated No Child Left Behind Act that didn't get approval. In
reviewing the waiver application, the department noted that New
Mexico's A-to-F system does not adequately address the achievement-gap
challenge among minority students.
However, both New Mexico's Public Education Department and the U.S.
Department of Education said they are working together to alter New
Mexico's waiver application so it can gain approval.
On Wednesday afternoon, the U.S. Department of Education announced that it is granting New Mexico a waiver.
In this legislative session, Skandera has continued to push for a
new teacher-evaluation system -- one based in large part upon student
test scores -- and for a new reading intervention/remediation law that
gives the state the right to hold back third-grade students who cannot
read to grade level.
As of Tuesday evening, the fate of those bills -- and competing
bills from other lawmakers -- was uncertain. Any and all of them may be
heard and voted upon on the House and/or Senate floor in the remaining
hours of the session.
The New Mexico Legislature last year also balked at confirming
Skandera. In 2011, Sen. Michael Sanchez, D-Belen, the Senate majority
floor leader and a member of the Senate Rules Committee, told reporters
that because Skandera has never worked as an educator, she might not
qualify as a department secretary under the state constitution.
Despite praise from U.S. Education Secretary Arne Duncan, who told
reporters last September that Skandera "is pushing every single day to
give every single child a great, great education," Skandera has since
come under fire for some of her decisions.
Some state superintendents and other critics criticized her for
initiating a questionable state audit of both public and charter schools
and for overruling the Public Education Commission's denial of three
state charters in 2010.
The Independent Source PAC, a liberal political-action group, has
continued to hammer away at Skandera over the past few months for a
number of reasons, including her hiring of Patricia Matthews -- a lawyer
for a legal firm that represents charter schools -- as the new director
of the Options for Parents Office, which oversees charter schools and
other alternative-learning venues.
The group has also knocked Skandera for hiring the wife of
Martinez's chief of staff, Keith Gardner, for an administrative
position, claiming that she and/or Martinez changed the requirements for
the job in order to help Stephanie Gardner land that job.
Skandera has also been criticized for dissolving standing advisory
committees on bilingual education, Indian education and Hispanic
education.
Last October, Skandera told
The New Mexican that she learned a
lot in her first 10 months on the job: "New Mexico is an unbelievably
relational state, and there is a beauty in that. Relationships are key
here; more than in other states."
On Tuesday morning, the governor told reporters in the Roundhouse
that Skandera will stay on, regardless. Asked if certain senators are
playing politics in denying Skandera a hearing, Martinez said, "You'd
have to ask the Senate. I don't know why they are refusing to do it.
"We're doing exactly what the Obama administration is saying we
should be doing. I don't understand what their pause is, but we are
going to move forward."
Contact Robert Nott at 986-3021 or rnott@sfnewmexican.com.